Parents of Rhiya Malin speak about her death during Channel Four Dispatches report into child safety

East London and West Essex Guardian Series: Rhiya Malin Rhiya Malin

The parents of a toddler who died at nursery recalled the moment they first saw their daughter’s lifeless body during a documentary on childcare safety last night.

The Channel Four Dispatches programme How Safe is Your Child’s Nursery? investigated safety at nurseries following government plans to allow each member of staff to look after more children.

Shatl and Jay Malin, whose daughter Rhiya died in 2007 at the Eton Manor Day Nursery in Chigwell, told the programme they first thought she had suffered a fit.

Mrs Malin, 33, said: “We went straight into A&E and there was a nursery staff member sitting on the floor and she was crying and holding onto one of the nurse’s hands.

“We were allowed to go to the resuscitation room and she was lying there, stripped down, and they just had a lot of tubes all over her.”

An inquest into Rhiya’s death recorded the narrative verdict that she had suffered a heart attack due to compression of the neck.

Her parents criticised the nursery’s former owners, Casterbridge Care and Education, who have since sold it, for re-registering the nursery before their first Ofsted inspection since Rhiya’s death.

Some detail about former nurseries that are linked to current ones can now be found on Ofsted’s website following a campaign by the Malins, but the way this is done was criticised on the programme.

Mr Malin, 42, said: “If you have one nursery with a history of complaints and they decide to move next door and change their name, this doesn’t help me make the link between the two companies.”

Ofsted said it was speaking to the Department for Education about changes to the law that it says need to be made before it can link open nurseries to closed establishments.

• Nursery nurse Kayley Murphy, of Greenfields, Loughton, was found guilty of health and safety breaches at Chelmsford Crown Court and is due to be sentenced together with Casterbridge, which admitted failings at an earlier hearing, on February 25.

Comments (2)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

9:58pm Tue 12 Feb 13

Cornbeefur says...

Was a terrible tragedy. You never stop worrying about your children and Mums know best with their own. Dreadful case.
Was a terrible tragedy. You never stop worrying about your children and Mums know best with their own. Dreadful case. Cornbeefur
  • Score: 0

8:04pm Thu 14 Feb 13

BelieveBJ says...

I am so so sorry for the loss of this sweet child....
Children belong at home with their parents at such a young age, where you can supervise them properly ....

RIP Rhiya....

Peace to her parents who have suffered such a terrible loss....unimaginable
.....
I am so so sorry for the loss of this sweet child.... Children belong at home with their parents at such a young age, where you can supervise them properly .... RIP Rhiya.... Peace to her parents who have suffered such a terrible loss....unimaginable ..... BelieveBJ
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree