A “monstrous” development which was to replace a landmark Walthamstow building has been voted down by councillors who slated its design, last night.

The Hurricane Snooker Hall in Hoe Street was to be torn down by developers and the site transformed into a huge new development.

However, the three-storey, 18-flat design received wide criticism at the council’s planning committee at the town hall.

Residents have largely objected to the plans since they were first revealed some months ago.

Originally, plans were for a six storey building containing 23 flats.

When these plans were submitted 97 residents objected, and a further ten objected to the amended version.

Guin Dimock, speaking on behalf of the applicant Ranjeet Singh, said the property was “under-used” and that they could not provide any social housing because of the cost of building work as the building is on a slope.

“The site is complex with regard to affordable housing. There are high construction costs and viability for affordable has been difficult to achieve.

“The site is on a steep slope, which impacts on the cost of development.

“The scheme provides high quality homes in a landmark building for this important gateway site.”

She added a community space is being provided for residents and there has been much interest in filling it.

Cllr Grace Williams: “This application does relate to an important site for many wards.

“There have been lots of objections from residents and businesses.

“It is lacking larger units and lacking in units with disability access.

“The application has already stated by objectors lacks the highest aspirations we should have for a site like this. It lacks the aspirations we should have for out borough.

“Should be on an understanding on what the community wants.”

Councillor Khan of High Street ward said: “This is a relatively small site but a very significant site for people living in this area.

“The developer did not make contact with any ward councillors this site borders.

“This junction has a historical significance.

“The applicants propose a building which dwarfs others – it is not in keeping with the area.”

Councillor Louise Mitchell from Chapel End ward also spoke out against the plans, stating no work was done with local residents over the community space.

Councillor Jenny Gray said: “The fact there are so many objections should make us realise this is not what residents want and I agree it is a feeble excuse for not offering any affordable housing.

“It is a prominent corner location. Next to Howard Road it looks extremely incongruous.

“I think Walthamstow deserves better.”

Cllr Allan Siggers called it the “wrong thing in the wrong place” and said there would be “no point” in having a planning committee if such plans were to be accepted.

The council committee unanimously voted to refuse the plans because of design, over development and consultation.