News RSS Feed


WALTHAMSTOW: Something fishy down at the library

9:55am Wednesday 5th December 2007

comment Comments (18)   Have your say »


IT HAS cost nearly £8,000 so far, but the new fish tank in Walthamstow's flagship library gives good value for money.

That is, at least, what Waltham Forest Council's cabinet member for libraries, Cllr Geraldine Reardon thinks.

She says the tank, which houses an array of brightly coloured fish in tastefully-designed surroundings, gives visitors to Walthamstow Library a better experience and make it a more popular destination too.

"The council is dedicated to delivering libraries with calming cultural and educational environments. Previously our facilities did not meet these expectations, which was reflected in their usage," Cllr Reardon explained.

"The current £10 million libraries investment programme is enriching and strengthening our services.

"Refurbished libraries are now more accessible, better equipped and - most importantly - more frequently used. Since April alone, Walthamstow Library has recorded over 350,000 visitors."

But some residents think the tank, which cost £7,263, is an enrichment too far, especially when it costs £705 a year to maintain.

Community campaigner, Kevin Lord, of Greenleaf Road, Walthamstow, was outraged when he found out how expensive the new tank was.

"We are cutting services for disabled people and services for everyone else, but it's nice to know we're looking after the fish," he said at the last Walthamstow West Community Council meeting.

Caroline Molloy, of the Save St James Street Library campaign, said fish tanks were no substitute for well-laid out, well-staffed libraries.

But another library lover, Janet Wright, had a different theory.

"The fish are useful for one thing. They are the only thing keeping an eye on the CDs and DVDs behind them, which are just walking out of the building.

"I presume that's the reason for buying them because I can't think of any other reason to get rid of books and put fish in their place," she said.

But the fish have gone down well with some. The building was commended at this week's Waltham Forest Design Awards and Cllr Reardon added: "Many visitors have expressed their delight with the new fish and children are particularly fascinated by them. The library now offers a more welcoming and exciting environment for visitors of all ages."


Your Say YourEast London and West Essex Guardian Series

Morris Hickey, Chigwell says...
10:49am Wed 5 Dec 07

No doubt intended to take attention away from the empty shelves following the wicked book bonfire.

Reader, e10 says...
12:21pm Wed 5 Dec 07

'calming cultural and educational environments'? Is that why a DJ was playing at full volume in the Central library a few saturdays ago, while children ran around shouting? The apes have taken over the zoo. Books individually worth hundreds of pounds have been destroyed, and these vandals are completely unashamed.

akram, London says...
1:40pm Wed 5 Dec 07

Reader wrote:
'calming cultural and educational environments'? Is that why a DJ was playing at full volume in the Central library a few saturdays ago, while children ran around shouting? The apes have taken over the zoo. Books individually worth hundreds of pounds have been destroyed, and these vandals are completely unashamed.
Thats racist say sorry.

CH, says...
2:58pm Wed 5 Dec 07

Honit soit qui mal y pense, akram.

Me, Here says...
3:21pm Wed 5 Dec 07

CH wrote:
Honit soit qui mal y pense, akram.
Exactly what I thought!!!

(whatever he said!!!!) :--)

Graham, London says...
3:23pm Wed 5 Dec 07

Me wrote:
CH wrote: Honit soit qui mal y pense, akram.
Exactly what I thought!!! (whatever he said!!!!) :--)
'Tis an old French saying...

Rich, E17 says...
4:04pm Wed 5 Dec 07

CH wrote: Honit soit qui mal y pense, akram.

It means "Bad things to those who think evil"

Well those poor kids can't read so may as well stare at fish. Then they can go home and stare at the tv!

reader, e10 says...
4:04pm Wed 5 Dec 07

Dear Akram,
unless Councillors are a separate species I don't get the point about racism: none was meant, that's for sure.
Perhaps I should have said Morlocks. If you haven't read it, I'm referring to a brilliant story by HG Wells, the Time Machine, about a future society divided between an idle and effete class who lie around all day, and a brutish ignorant underclass which eats them after dark. I've got a nasty feeling you won't find it in the library these days, however.

rich, e17 says...
4:06pm Wed 5 Dec 07

Thats racist say sorry.


Akram - can you explain the racisism here please?

Sceptic, E17 says...
4:09pm Wed 5 Dec 07

OK, if I tell you that "honi soit qui mal y pense" means "Evil be to whoever thinks evil", will someone tell me what was racist about Reader's comment?

We don't know the race of anyone involved. Pointing out the difference between the councillor's fantasy of a "calming environment" and the noisy reality isn't racist - the councillor quoted is white, anyway.

Or is Akram presuming that anyone causing disruption must be from an ethnic minority? Now that really is racist.

Walthamster, E 17 says...
4:23pm Wed 5 Dec 07

All show, glitzy surface, pretty frivolities. Nothing real or valuable. No books that might challenge or educate, just easy reading to keep people quiet. Junk food for the brain.

Some of these councillors have university degrees. What chance of that for the children they so patronisingly presume couldn't cope with real literature?

Jonathan Baddeley, Walthamstow says...
5:04pm Wed 5 Dec 07

Reardon must be insane. After not responding to the outcry over book destruction she can say wonderful things about a fish tank with a straight face? She is clearly out of touch with the residents of our town and impervious to public opinion of her incompetence.

Freddie, Chingford says...
5:38pm Wed 5 Dec 07

And dont forget we'll also be told how wonderful this is for the community in our great local 'free' paper WFM, which everyone knows stands for W aste of F -cking M oney!!!!!

Caroline, Walthamstow says...
9:55pm Wed 5 Dec 07

Come to the St James St Library Campaign's fun day, this Saturday (8th) at 2pm outside the St James library on Coppermill Lane - free face painting with Carole from Big Brother, music, bring a book to swap, and making xmas cards to tell the council what you think of the library cuts and closures. All welcome! (rain or shine!). See www.stjamesstlibrary

.wordpress.com for more details.

Chris, Essex says...
12:08am Thu 6 Dec 07

From bread and circuses of Roman times to fish and pantomimes a la LB of WF councillors.
If these councillors have university qualifications what does that say about the quality of those qualifications? The curriculum must have been low on commonsense and ethics

Incredible, London says...
2:02am Wed 12 Dec 07

It is amazing how Akram can take things out of context. This is England and they have a way of saying things. In this context I cannot see no offence. Don't create something out of nothing. Keep to the point - library issue and not racism!

dorotheen strass, says...
1:10pm Wed 12 Dec 07

Beauty, like cultural activities and venues, is not something the council has been very concerned with over recent years. However, the fish at the library are an attractive and soothing sight when you come in. I like them and I applaud the Library for providing them. PS, books that may have gone and not held anymore in the borough can be ordered from other boroughs across London. I recently ordered a book I had checked out before from WF and it came within 2 weeks from Wandsworth. I find the new Central library much better and more effective than the old.

mdj, e10 says...
12:05am Thu 13 Dec 07

Dear Dorotheen,
thankfully, ordering books has never been a problem. But you may not realise how much it hurts to find that books that this council once provided, which WE paid for, have been pulped, books some of which are out of print and can be found on Amazon for £200!If you like fish tanks, do you expect them at the Town hall? The benefits office? The bus station? Hardly. That fish tank may seem like a small issue, but it represents vandalism to many of us, who know what a public library means, and know that this Council has sacked all its qualified librarians and museums staff, in order to subsidise its own cronies, at your expense. If you're not angry, you don't really know what's been going on.

Comments are closed on this article.

Local Advertisers


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »