News RSS Feed


LEYTON: Security fencing at school "will look like concentration camp"

11:58am Thursday 7th August 2008

comment Comments (3)   Have your say »


CONTROVERSIAL plans to erect tall barbed wire fencing around a school plagued by criminals will make it look like a concentration camp, a meeting heard.

Barclay School, in Canterbury Road, Leyton, wants to replace its 1.8 metre high Edwardian railings with 3 metre barbed wire-topped gates in response to two recent break-ins and vandalism.

Three residents spoke out about the proposal at a meeting of the council's planning committee on Tuesday, August 5.

One of them, Peter Brightwell said: "The new fences will make the school look like a concentration camp. This will not do. They have done a very good job with new fencing at Leyton Sixth Form College in Essex Road.

"I consider something like that is much more attractive. Aren't we going to have a beautiful fence but instead an ugly fence?"

The school's chair of governors Robin Thompson-Clarke said: "Pupils' safety is the first priority while their education must be the second priority."

He added burglars had stolen 40 lap tops from the school and that had meant pupils had been denied an information technology suite for a long time.

PC Paul Hawkins, a crime prevention and design advisor, said: "Barclay is a school which has been at risk of crime for a long time. I would recommend this fencing as a way of deterring criminals from targeting the school."

Cllr Farooq Qureshi said: "I would like the opportunity to meet with residents to discuss things further. For this reason I would request that members defer this item."

The council consulted 81 homes in surrounding Peterborough Road, Essex Road, and Canterbury Road and received a petition with 33 signatures objecting to the plans.

It claims that the proposed fences are an excessive measure and alternatives, such as CCTV cameras, should be explored.

Speaking after the meeting, Cllr Chris Robbins said: "I have agreed to convene a meeting with the school, councillors and local residents to see if we can find a way through current difficulties."

Councillors unanimously agreed to defer the item.


Your Say YourEast London and West Essex Guardian Series

Helen, Walthamstow, Walthamstow says...
12:24pm Thu 7 Aug 08

As a governor of another primary school in Waltham Forest, I was shocked to hear about Barclay's proposal. This fence, 9ft tall with barbed wire on top, sounds appalling and will give children and their parents, and those considering signing up for the school, an impression that it is not a safe place to be. There are many other measures the school could take to protect its equipment and its buildings against intruders (burglar alarms, CCTV, security doors that need a fob to open, a locked store for laptops etc) before going down this path. Such an intrusive fence also gives a poor impression of the neighbourhood and I am not surprised that local residents are upset.

franks, leyton says...
2:20pm Thu 7 Aug 08

What has this to do with a concentration camp?

basillio, Walthamstow says...
3:18pm Fri 8 Aug 08

What is so depressing about this is that at the planning committee we saw no examples of installed fencing similar to that being proposed. All we were told was that it had been installed "successfully" elsewhere at other schools.

I'm suspect such fencing would deter break ins. It would also be a brutal response - reinforcing the impression the world outside the play ground is violent, brutal and has to be held back. And that children can only be safe at school if they're surrounded by an iron wall.

What's wrong with planting a thick hedge of pyracantha behind the existing Edwardian railings? I believe that the Masai use it to stop lions from carry off cows from their villages.

Comments are closed on this article.

Local Advertisers


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »