Get involved: send your pictures, video, news & views by texting WFNEWS to 80360, or email us
12:45pm Wednesday 7th April 2010 in News By Carl Brown
THE Liberal Democrat local election campaign is in disarray after it emerged that three senior councillors, including the council’s deputy leader, have been ditched by the party.
Hopes that the Lib Dems, who currently run the council in coalition with Labour, could become the biggest party look to be in ruins after the party confirmed leader John Macklin, cabinet member for environment Bob Belam and chief whip Bob Carey will not stand for the party on May 6.
A party spokesman admitted the move was the result of an internal dispute, but did not provide any further detail.
But the Guardian understands the party’s decision to ditch the three followed a bitter row over an attempt by members sitting on the Walthamstow executive to de-select Cllr Carey, who represents Chapel End ward with Cllrs Macklin and Belam.
Cllr Macklin admitted there has been concern about the executive’s candidate selection for some time.
He said: “There has been a dispute about issues around candidates selected in several wards, including Chapel End.
“There has been concern about inappropriate candidates being selected for target level seats.
“The issue has been going on for several months and I don't think it is something that has been completely resolved.
“Myself, Bob Carey and Bob Belam are the best people to represent Chapel End ward because we have worked the area for years and have listened and acted on residents' complaints.”
Cllr Macklin said he was “bitterly disappointed” that he was having to talk in public about the row and conceded it is “not good” for the party.
He added that he had not decided whether to stand as an independent.
A spokesman for the Lib Dem London region party said: "The local and regional executive have agreed the conclusion of internal mediation and no members have been suspended.”
The Walthamstow Executive is made up of members and activists including Cllr Johar Khan, Cllr Bob Wheatley and Walthamstow parliamentary candidate Farid Ahmed.
Comments(76)
Helen, Walthamstow
says...
1:14pm Wed 7 Apr 10
RichieA70
says...
2:04pm Wed 7 Apr 10
marsdan
says...
2:38pm Wed 7 Apr 10
April Showers
says...
3:16pm Wed 7 Apr 10
Pamella
says...
3:22pm Wed 7 Apr 10
April Showers
says...
3:36pm Wed 7 Apr 10
Dave Hall
says...
3:36pm Wed 7 Apr 10
Janet1
says...
3:40pm Wed 7 Apr 10
Janet1
says...
3:46pm Wed 7 Apr 10
lillybet1
says...
4:19pm Wed 7 Apr 10
jack de large
says...
5:40pm Wed 7 Apr 10
April Showers
says...
6:14pm Wed 7 Apr 10
Janet1
says...
6:45pm Wed 7 Apr 10
jack de large
says...
6:49pm Wed 7 Apr 10
Silent Majority 2009
says...
7:53pm Wed 7 Apr 10
April Showers
says...
8:22pm Wed 7 Apr 10
April Showers
says...
8:32pm Wed 7 Apr 10
Earle Martin
says...
8:52pm Wed 7 Apr 10
wheeler_dealer_of Cathall
says...
10:32pm Wed 7 Apr 10
Robert19
says...
11:15pm Wed 7 Apr 10
Janet1
says...
11:48pm Wed 7 Apr 10
Mr Bernard
says...
12:43am Thu 8 Apr 10
Janet1
says...
12:49am Thu 8 Apr 10
E17006
says...
3:42am Thu 8 Apr 10
lillybet1
says...
7:14am Thu 8 Apr 10
jack de large
says...
8:10am Thu 8 Apr 10
Helen, Walthamstow
says...
9:48am Thu 8 Apr 10
lillybet1
says...
9:52am Thu 8 Apr 10
Techno2
says...
10:11am Thu 8 Apr 10
Helen, Walthamstow wrote:Anyway, the point has been made - people should understand that is going on: the LibDems have a problem with a relatively newly formed faction that has entered the party, centred around Mr Khan and Farid Ahmed. They have tried to stage a coup in some wards and run the party's general election campaign from the top down using money and bought-in manpower rather than activists, in the weird belief that the electorate wouldn't notice.
Why has Techno2's main comment been removed as well as two others? I do hope it is not because Johar Khan and Farid Ahmed have complained. They have put themselves up for election and taken part in a process that has prevented leading members of their party from standing in election, and now they have to take the flack or provide a sesnible explanation for their decisions.
lillybet1
says...
11:56am Thu 8 Apr 10
lillybet1
says...
11:58am Thu 8 Apr 10
lillybet1
says...
12:03pm Thu 8 Apr 10
ceegriffin
says...
12:55pm Thu 8 Apr 10
Jayish
says...
1:07pm Thu 8 Apr 10
Techno2
says...
1:56pm Thu 8 Apr 10
Jayish wrote:The LibDems at a National level
May be all of us who are crucifying the Lib Dems should stand back and think as to why would a party get rid of the high ranking councillors this late in the run up to the election? I am certain the Lid Dem Walthamstow executive and the London Regional must have done every thing in their power to avoid this from happening. Deselecting any high ranking candidate must have been a very difficult decision to make and not taken lightly by any party. May be there was something seriously flowed with the three deselected councillors. From what I know they have been councillors for quiet some time now and we all know what happens to those who are left in power too long, remember Magi Thatcher’s and then Tony Blair. May be we should applause the Lib Dems for risking all to get their house in order. May be we should all now give them our full support.
Jayish
says...
3:27pm Thu 8 Apr 10
Fedupwithitall
says...
4:05pm Thu 8 Apr 10
Jayish wrote:Actually Jayish, I for one am grateful for Techno's insight into this unpleasant affair, which is as bad as the Labour deselection fiasco when candidates were eventually imposed in some wards. We need people to blow the lid on what many of us have long suspected were morally corrupt goings-on amongst our local representatives. Thanks for keeping us informed Techno2.
I think you should stay focused on the issue in the article Techno2 and refrain from dragging other candidates into this issue. It sounds like you have a personal axe to grind with Councillor Khan and Mr. Ahmed or you are waving the flag for one of the other Parties or even the deselected candidates. Ooh your comment reeks of venom.
Helen, Walthamstow
says...
5:04pm Thu 8 Apr 10
wheeler_dealer_of Cathall
says...
5:14pm Thu 8 Apr 10
Janet1
says...
5:23pm Thu 8 Apr 10
Jayish wrote:Your comment is strange, Jayish. I’ve reread Techno2’s comment twice and cannot see what you are complaining about. Techno is focusing on the issue. Your own sympathies seem to lie with the people who deselected sitting councillors, including the party leader, in the run-up to an election. To the rest of us, that looks like electoral suicide. I feel sorry for genuine Liberals who have given years of activism to this party – and I’m not even a LibDem supporter.
I think you should stay focused on the issue in the article Techno2 and refrain from dragging other candidates into this issue. It sounds like you have a personal axe to grind with Councillor Khan and Mr. Ahmed or you are waving the flag for one of the other Parties or even the deselected candidates. Ooh your comment reeks of venom.
Jayish
says...
5:35pm Thu 8 Apr 10
Fedupwithitall
says...
5:44pm Thu 8 Apr 10
wheeler_dealer_of Cathall wrote:Unfortunately Wheeler_dealer you too seem to have an axe to grind and are perpetuating the myth that surrounds the Labour deselections. Yes, there were some black councillors deselected but there were also asian councillors deselected too, notably Faiz Yunis and Tarsem Bhogal. You're entitled to your opinion that Naheed Asghar is both incompetent and inexperienced, but having met her on several ocassions I am convinced neither is true. You also don't seem to credit the electorate with much intelligence when it comes to voting - I think the majority of us are intelligent enough to look beyond the personalities and examine the policies.
Techno2 is obviously an insider to know so much of what is happening within the libdems. However it seems s/he is not helping the libdems with such comments, and like Jayish, I think s/he has a personal axe to grind. However, I have to admit that this is very similar to what happened to the Labour lot recently - a coup manufactured by certain individuals. They ended up deselecting Black councillors such as Milton Martin and replacing them with unknowns such as Naheed (councillor Asghar's daughter). Clearly not a decision based on competencies or experience. In reply to the comment about having good reason to deselect standing councillors, I would only like to say that in this case (and that of Labour) that the only reason for deselection is due to personal favours and personal agendas, and that these agendas always seem to be more important to these sickening individuals than the parties they serve. Lets face it, these local elections are more about personalities than parties. Good luck to the 3 deselected Lib- dems.
Janet1
says...
5:47pm Thu 8 Apr 10
April Showers
says...
5:50pm Thu 8 Apr 10
Helen, Walthamstow
says...
6:32pm Thu 8 Apr 10
Jayish wrote:If anyone is insulting out intelligence, Jayish, it's you.
Fedupwithitall (it's obvious you are) It is also obvious that you hold a very limited knowledge of what lengths members of the other parties and discredited candidates will go to, to try and discredit other worthy candidates or opponents. It is a shame that you fall for such obvious juvenile tactics that insult not only your inelegance but also the inelegance of others commenting on this topic. Well tried any way!!
Angel786
says...
6:46pm Thu 8 Apr 10
jack de large
says...
10:31pm Thu 8 Apr 10
Janet1
says...
10:52pm Thu 8 Apr 10
Liz10
says...
12:18am Fri 9 Apr 10
Janet1 wrote:I must say that techno & co seem to know a lot more about this then anybodyelse. How comes?
Jayish wrote: I think you should stay focused on the issue in the article Techno2 and refrain from dragging other candidates into this issue. It sounds like you have a personal axe to grind with Councillor Khan and Mr. Ahmed or you are waving the flag for one of the other Parties or even the deselected candidates. Ooh your comment reeks of venom.Your comment is strange, Jayish. I’ve reread Techno2’s comment twice and cannot see what you are complaining about. Techno is focusing on the issue. Your own sympathies seem to lie with the people who deselected sitting councillors, including the party leader, in the run-up to an election. To the rest of us, that looks like electoral suicide. I feel sorry for genuine Liberals who have given years of activism to this party – and I’m not even a LibDem supporter. I have no axe to grind for any of the parties. But a LibDem majority would have brought a much-needed change of power. I am disgusted that this ham-fisted politicking has damaged hopes of cleaning out this council.
Liz10
says...
12:27am Fri 9 Apr 10
Janet1 wrote:How do you know who deselected sitting councillors? just by reading tehcno's comments? I think that is rather naive of you. Do we even know the process? Do we even know the background? Do we even care? So why do people like you and techno always make out like you know everything or the truth...........
Jayish wrote: I think you should stay focused on the issue in the article Techno2 and refrain from dragging other candidates into this issue. It sounds like you have a personal axe to grind with Councillor Khan and Mr. Ahmed or you are waving the flag for one of the other Parties or even the deselected candidates. Ooh your comment reeks of venom.Your comment is strange, Jayish. I’ve reread Techno2’s comment twice and cannot see what you are complaining about. Techno is focusing on the issue. Your own sympathies seem to lie with the people who deselected sitting councillors, including the party leader, in the run-up to an election. To the rest of us, that looks like electoral suicide. I feel sorry for genuine Liberals who have given years of activism to this party – and I’m not even a LibDem supporter. I have no axe to grind for any of the parties. But a LibDem majority would have brought a much-needed change of power. I am disgusted that this ham-fisted politicking has damaged hopes of cleaning out this council.
Techno2
says...
9:22am Fri 9 Apr 10
Liz10 wrote:Very good point. I had to speak to several people over a fair period of time to realize what was going on and I have had doubts about it myself from time to time because you don't really like to believe it even when you see it and get told things by people who are angry and distressed. Everyone has an angle.
Janet1 wrote:How do you know who deselected sitting councillors? just by reading tehcno's comments? I think that is rather naive of you. Do we even know the process? Do we even know the background? Do we even care? So why do people like you and techno always make out like you know everything or the truth...........Jayish wrote: I think you should stay focused on the issue in the article Techno2 and refrain from dragging other candidates into this issue. It sounds like you have a personal axe to grind with Councillor Khan and Mr. Ahmed or you are waving the flag for one of the other Parties or even the deselected candidates. Ooh your comment reeks of venom.Your comment is strange, Jayish. I’ve reread Techno2’s comment twice and cannot see what you are complaining about. Techno is focusing on the issue. Your own sympathies seem to lie with the people who deselected sitting councillors, including the party leader, in the run-up to an election. To the rest of us, that looks like electoral suicide. I feel sorry for genuine Liberals who have given years of activism to this party – and I’m not even a LibDem supporter. I have no axe to grind for any of the parties. But a LibDem majority would have brought a much-needed change of power. I am disgusted that this ham-fisted politicking has damaged hopes of cleaning out this council.
Helen, Walthamstow
says...
9:41am Fri 9 Apr 10
Janet1
says...
10:06am Fri 9 Apr 10
sonofturpin
says...
10:15am Fri 9 Apr 10
Janet1
says...
10:20am Fri 9 Apr 10
wfmywordmybond
says...
11:48am Fri 9 Apr 10
Janet1 wrote:Janet - below is the link to the Walthamstow Lib Dem contact page.
Helen, I have heard of what you describe, from a long-time Labour Party activist who was distressed at witnessing this. I didn’t know it was also happening in the LibDem party.
I too would like to know who else is on the LibDem executive.
wfmywordmybond
says...
11:49am Fri 9 Apr 10
Dave Hall
says...
11:52am Fri 9 Apr 10
Janet1
says...
12:25pm Fri 9 Apr 10
Tom Thumb
says...
6:16pm Fri 9 Apr 10
Dave Hall wrote:Dave Hall hits the spot. Vote for an Independent, Vote Green - go out and vote, but don't reward this inept crew. If you vote for any of the three main parties you are just maintaining the status quo. There is very little difference between them.
This shambolic behaviour just before an election will just ensure that the Lib Dems do not take the leader's role in the new council. Presumably just to satisfy a factional interest. The Labour Party used to do these things differently. I remember the GLC elections in May 1981. Labour won, and then the day after the poll they threw out the leader (Andrew McIntosh - I didn't remember him, I had to look him up) and elected Ken Livingstone as leader. You're supposed to win the election first before throwing out the leader. Vote for an Independent, Vote Green - go out and vote, but don't reward this inept crew.
everoptimistic
says...
11:19pm Fri 9 Apr 10
Walthamstonian
says...
12:21am Sat 10 Apr 10
E17006
says...
5:46pm Sat 10 Apr 10
E17006
says...
5:47pm Sat 10 Apr 10
Redfox
says...
11:28pm Sat 10 Apr 10
wfmywordmybond
says...
9:16pm Sun 11 Apr 10
lillybet1
says...
9:45am Mon 12 Apr 10
lillybet1
says...
10:01am Mon 12 Apr 10
Essex Man
says...
10:34am Tue 13 Apr 10
fabster
says...
11:42am Tue 13 Apr 10
Techno2
says...
12:15pm Tue 13 Apr 10
lillybet1 wrote:When you say 'since', without clarifiying that he does not in fact live there now, I do hope you are not meaning to give us a false impression that he actually still lives there. If that is that an inadvertant ommission, would you like to correct the fale impression and let us know in what year he last actually lived in the ward he represents?
Apologies correction to last comment from myself, unlike some I get facts wrong and say sorry..... James O'Rourke grew up in the High Street Ward since 1967. This makes him committed to the residents of HIS ward and has proved it over the last 4 years. The saying is "you can please some of the people some of the time but you cant please all the people all of the time". I repeat he has worked very hard and will continue to do so.
forlorn
says...
12:38pm Tue 13 Apr 10
E17006
says...
4:50am Wed 14 Apr 10
forlorn
says...
3:55pm Thu 22 Apr 10
Walthamster
says...
8:50pm Thu 22 Apr 10
Need a change? Search thousands of jobs locally and across the UK.
Search Now »
Find friendship and romance online with Two’s Company
Search Now »
Tens of thousands of houses and flats for sale and rent.
Search Now »
Every major make and model, thousands of options to choose from.
Search Now »
Morris Hickey says...
12:50pm Wed 7 Apr 10