Essex County Council are criticised over their maintenance of the county's roads

Lloyd Butler may have to wait three months before Essex County Council make a decision

Lloyd Butler may have to wait three months before Essex County Council make a decision

First published in Epping Forest
Last updated
East London and West Essex Guardian Series: Photograph of the Author by , Reporter

A driver is furious after his car was nearly written off in a collision with a pothole, and the council lost his claim for compensation.

Lloyd Butler, of Ivy Chimneys Road in Epping, was driving towards along England’s Lane towards Debden, when his car struck the water filled hole.

His wheel was destroyed along with a shock absorber and a tyre rod, but he was more shocked by the response of Essex County Council.

The 34 year-old manager of a builder’s merchants said: “I think it is disgusting.

“The system is awful, I phoned up to find out how my application was going and they said that they had no record of it.

“I had to do it all again and now they tell me that a decision could take up to three months.

Mr Butler said that roads in the district are being neglected by the council, and that it is reluctant to take responsibility for the problems.

He added: “I just have not got £1,000 to pay out. The council should be looking after the roads, a pothole that big does not just come overnight.

“They said that I should have swerved to avoid it but there was a car coming the other way.

“Should I have killed us both to avoid a pothole?

“I was also told that I should have been looking at the road, but the hole was full of water. It wasn’t until I went back the next day that I saw just how big the hole is.”

A spokesman for the council said that twelve separate potholes have been identified and filled by its highways inspectors in England’s Lane in the last year, and six have been reported by the public.

He refused to discuss Mr Butler’s claim but added: “All compensation claims are investigated fully, and costs are only paid if the council feels it would be held liable in court for having breached its statutory duties as the highway authority to maintain the highway.

“All claims are given the same legal consideration, whether the claim is for minor damage to a vehicle or for personal injury.”

Comments (2)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

8:05am Thu 28 Feb 13

UKIP-local says...

Lloyd made a big mistake filing his claim in his own name. If he added "Hanningfield" as a second name by deed poll the claim would have been paid without query.

Pot holes are boring but costly if not promptly attended to. Lloyd knows that and so will the council tax payers when the bills for repair start coming in. Better maintenance and better observation would save money even at the salaries they offer in County Hall.
Lloyd made a big mistake filing his claim in his own name. If he added "Hanningfield" as a second name by deed poll the claim would have been paid without query. Pot holes are boring but costly if not promptly attended to. Lloyd knows that and so will the council tax payers when the bills for repair start coming in. Better maintenance and better observation would save money even at the salaries they offer in County Hall. UKIP-local
  • Score: 0

11:21am Thu 28 Feb 13

HottRedMan says...

I find it ridiculous I have to inform many councils via emails of potholes and subsidence in the road. Some are quick to repair them. While others dont bother or take their time.
The amount of money the council and government make out of motorists it takes the pee that we have some of the crapest roads in the world imo.
Over the past 3-4 months, due to the amount of heavy ad constant rain, this is what makes it worse and when no repair is done, the surface just digs up. One of the WORST councils I have come across is Tower Hamlets. Very bad road surfaces, failure to address potholes urgently and road markings never repainted and in some cases barely visible.

These councils as in the UK only realise when a life is lost then they come up with the same old stupid bull junk line of "where lessons could be learned"
I find it ridiculous I have to inform many councils via emails of potholes and subsidence in the road. Some are quick to repair them. While others dont bother or take their time. The amount of money the council and government make out of motorists it takes the pee that we have some of the crapest roads in the world imo. Over the past 3-4 months, due to the amount of heavy ad constant rain, this is what makes it worse and when no repair is done, the surface just digs up. One of the WORST councils I have come across is Tower Hamlets. Very bad road surfaces, failure to address potholes urgently and road markings never repainted and in some cases barely visible. These councils as in the UK only realise when a life is lost then they come up with the same old stupid bull junk line of "where lessons could be learned" HottRedMan
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree