Pine tree falls on a house in The Drive, South Woodford

Krishna Kunwar

Krishna Kunwar and house owner Raj Kumar

Krishna Kunwar and house owner Raj Kumar

house owner Raj Kumar

Man 'lucky' to escape death after 100ft pine falls on South Woodford home

Man 'lucky' to escape death after 100ft pine falls on South Woodford home

First published in Redbridge East London and West Essex Guardian Series: Photograph of the Author by , Senior reporter

QUESTIONS are being asked of Redbridge council after a 100ft pine tree fell onto a South Woodford home.

Domestic helper Krishna Kunwar, 38, narrowly escaped being killed in the incident, after leaving a playroom just moments before it was destroyed by the tree which fell from the next door neighbour's garden.

He said: “I was cleaning in there and walked through to the pool room next door.

“There was a loud crash and I went back and the room had been destroyed.

"I am lucky to be alive and thank God I was not killed.”

Raj and Neelam Kumar, who own the house in The Drive, were both out at the time and were shocked when they heard about the incident which happened last Wednesday.

Mrs Kumar, 65, said: “My son called me and said there’s been an accident a tree has fallen on the house. Then he said something about Krishna, but I couldn’t hear because the signal was bad.

“I just panicked, because I thought Krishna has been hurt. It was a relief when I got home and found he was alive.

“But of course the damage is terrible. Our grandson plays in that room with his friends. If it had fallen an hour later he would have been home from school and in there.

“The thought makes me shiver.”

Mr Kumar, 65, a director of a travel company in Gants Hill, said he expected repairs to run to as much as £70,000.

“What angers me is that we asked our neighbour to chop this tree down some time ago, but the council refused him permission,” he added.

“It was leaning over very precariously, and look what has happened. Why was this tree allowed to remain?”

Neighbour Seeralan Govindaraju, 50, wrote to Redbridge Council about the tree in 2009.

He said: “When our neighbours said they were worried about the tree falling, of course we applied to have it removed.

“But the council just refused outright, they never even came to inspect it. I feel that they should at least have come to evaluate it.”

Mr Kumar is worried about another tree at the front of his property and says he contacted the council about it before last week’s incident, but that they refused consent to remove it.

A spokesman for Redbridge council said: "Redbridge Council refused permission for the complete removal of this tree in 2009 as the applicant failed to provide evidence to justify its removal.

"As part of the decision the Council made it very clear that in order to have sufficient evidence to make such a decision a climbing inspection needed to take place.

"Before the Council can agree to the removal of important protected trees, it must be provided with evidence to justify this.

"This was clearly requested and advised by the Council in its decision. None was provided as part of the application nor subsequently.

"The owner of the tree/applicant is responsible for the tree's safety and therefore for arranging for the necessary inspection and further application to the Council; it is not the responsibility of the Council.

"After giving this advice the Council did not receive any further applications for the removal of the tree."

The Council says it has no record of any application to remove any trees at the front of the Kumar's property.

Comments (5)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

10:26pm Tue 27 Nov 12

Cornbeefur says...

No win no fee?
No win no fee? Cornbeefur
  • Score: 0

10:08am Wed 28 Nov 12

Cornbeefur says...

Just looked at the additional photos, I mean is it wise to stand posing for the camera under a semi-collapsed roof?
Just looked at the additional photos, I mean is it wise to stand posing for the camera under a semi-collapsed roof? Cornbeefur
  • Score: 0

4:50pm Sat 1 Dec 12

Kacey79 says...

I have had a very similar experience with redbridge council regarding the refusal to remove a dangerous overhanging tree in my back garden.

During a particularly harsh winter, the branches fell on my car and damaged the bonnet and roof badly. The car was out of action for 2 months and I had to use public transport to work during the winter months.

A Mr Wessel at the council who is in charge of the forestry section needs to be questioned as to his decisions to protect trees over humans. I wonder whether Mr Wessel has any large protected trees in his own garden? Would he care to post pictures publicly to show us all how he too lives with the very real danger of loss of life or of his wife and children due to dangerous trees? No, I didn't think so.
I have had a very similar experience with redbridge council regarding the refusal to remove a dangerous overhanging tree in my back garden. During a particularly harsh winter, the branches fell on my car and damaged the bonnet and roof badly. The car was out of action for 2 months and I had to use public transport to work during the winter months. A Mr Wessel at the council who is in charge of the forestry section needs to be questioned as to his decisions to protect trees over humans. I wonder whether Mr Wessel has any large protected trees in his own garden? Would he care to post pictures publicly to show us all how he too lives with the very real danger of loss of life or of his wife and children due to dangerous trees? No, I didn't think so. Kacey79
  • Score: 0

6:13pm Sat 1 Dec 12

Bobkji says...

They had asked them to pose but once down it was safe enough to walk around the ruins. There are two more trees in the front garden that need chopping but the council state they are "safe"!!
They had asked them to pose but once down it was safe enough to walk around the ruins. There are two more trees in the front garden that need chopping but the council state they are "safe"!! Bobkji
  • Score: 0

7:49am Mon 3 Dec 12

stickmanny says...

Kacey79 wrote:
I have had a very similar experience with redbridge council regarding the refusal to remove a dangerous overhanging tree in my back garden.

During a particularly harsh winter, the branches fell on my car and damaged the bonnet and roof badly. The car was out of action for 2 months and I had to use public transport to work during the winter months.

A Mr Wessel at the council who is in charge of the forestry section needs to be questioned as to his decisions to protect trees over humans. I wonder whether Mr Wessel has any large protected trees in his own garden? Would he care to post pictures publicly to show us all how he too lives with the very real danger of loss of life or of his wife and children due to dangerous trees? No, I didn't think so.
Hold on: there is a clear statement from the council here that a climbing inspection was not performed, the implication being that the inspection had to be arranged and paid for by the owner of the tree?
[quote][p][bold]Kacey79[/bold] wrote: I have had a very similar experience with redbridge council regarding the refusal to remove a dangerous overhanging tree in my back garden. During a particularly harsh winter, the branches fell on my car and damaged the bonnet and roof badly. The car was out of action for 2 months and I had to use public transport to work during the winter months. A Mr Wessel at the council who is in charge of the forestry section needs to be questioned as to his decisions to protect trees over humans. I wonder whether Mr Wessel has any large protected trees in his own garden? Would he care to post pictures publicly to show us all how he too lives with the very real danger of loss of life or of his wife and children due to dangerous trees? No, I didn't think so.[/p][/quote]Hold on: there is a clear statement from the council here that a climbing inspection was not performed, the implication being that the inspection had to be arranged and paid for by the owner of the tree? stickmanny
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree