Waltham Forest News RSS Feed


WALTHAM FOREST: No contracts for £1m council payments


THE company which is being investigated for the alleged fraudulent use of taxpayers’ money was paid £1million by the council without a contract being signed, it has emerged.

The payment to EduAction, from funds earmarked to help the most deprived residents through the Better Neighbourhood Initiative (BNI), was made in 2006 without tendering rules to prevent fraud being followed.

A leaked document shows the seven-figure sum was paid to the company for programmes labelled Curriculum Development (£77,604), Alternative Provision (£342,363) and Late Arrivals Project (£474,941).

Two other schemes known as ‘Vision 12’ and ‘Notschool’ were approved in May 2006 by the Local Strategic Partnership (LSP), which is the accountable body for BNI and its predecessor Neighbourhood Renewal Fund (NRF) and is chaired by council leader Clyde Loakes.

The LSP originally agreed that contracts should be drafted, although a review by consultants PriceWaterhouseCoopers(PWC) found this had not been done.

Details of the deal will cause further embarrassment to the authority, which was found to be responsible for a widespread and long-term systematic failure to manage millions of pounds earmarked to address inequalities.

Whistleblowers claim EduAction, which ran education in Waltham Forest until April, used money from NRF to boost profits.

EduAction’s lawyers intervened to block the results of a council investigation into the affair being made public last month.

The authority has now passed its findings to the police and the matter has also been referred to the Public Accounts Committee.

Cllr Loakes has refused to accept responsibility for the failings and says the problems were the result of council procedures not being followed and have nothing to do with the LSP.

Five council officers are currently under investigation for failing to report claims that EduAction had misused £240,000 it was given to run the Youth At Risk programme in 2004.

All contracts invloving two of the officers are being examined.

Nick Tiratsoo, whose research uncovered a number of BNI/NRF failings, has called for an independent investigation.

He said: “The council simply handed over about one million pounds of public money to pay the company for some very vaguely defined programmes.

“With no contract in place, LBWF was then unable to determine what was achieved, or take corrective action when things went wrong.”

A council spokeswoman said: “The findings of this investigation are now the subject of a disciplinary investigation.”


Your Say Your Guardian

mdj, e10 says...
11:20pm Wed 13 Aug 08

Would any of this have come to light without the dedicated work of a private citizen? We have Scrutiny Committees of Councillors: will some of them stand up and explain what they were doing while this was going on?

Technomist, Walthamstow says...
12:34am Thu 14 Aug 08

Although we have all the ingredients in place for evil capitalist-style corruption and no evidence of safeguards that work, I am so pleased that under Councillor Loakes we can trust all of our Council's Officers and all our elected representatives not to give in to such evil temptation and take personal advantage of the situation.

With the up-coming Olympics, I look at Beijing, the current host of the Olympics and am sure they will be jealous indeed. Jealous that here in Waltham Forest, one of the host boroughs in 2012, we have our own Dear Leader, a Great Helmsman of our Borough, who can lead us towards a glorious and uncorrupted future. Our Beloved Councillor Loakes - a figure within our humble and devoted community of admirers who is as great in his vision and control of events of their own much missed leader, Chairman Mao. Our Chinese cousins in Beijing know that such a man will never betray the sacred trust given to him by the people of Waltham Forest, by his comrades, cadres and workers.

Under Councillor Loakes, I am full of confidence that our selfless body of councillors (who self-sacrificingly accept a mere million pounds a year of public money between them in democratically voted allowances) are providing us with excellent, upright and accountable local leadership and governance. With Councillor Loakes in the vanguard, we can ensure that nothing untoward has gone on in our progressive and well-managed borough.

Technomist, Walthamstow says...
12:42am Thu 14 Aug 08

Long Live Councillor Loakes! A Thousand years to Councillor Loakes! Long Live the Party!

carolinem, walthamstow says...
10:34am Thu 14 Aug 08

A million quid of our taxpayer money handed over without even a basic written contract??? When is someone at the very top (ie Loakes) going to do the honourable thing and take responsibility for this disgraceful mess? The sums involved were large enough to keep open St James St Library, pay for some new gardens or play parks or even a good chunk of a cinema - but instead Loakes appears to have let them be used to secretively subsidise a private contractor, with not even the most basic procedures followed, and no tangible benefit to the community that this money was supposed to be for.

Technomist, Walthamstow says...
10:40am Thu 14 Aug 08

Carolinem - you show insufficient respect to our great Dear Leader. The people don't need books. They need WFM stuffed through their letter boxes as often as possible. We must all learn as much as we can about the sage doings and wisdom of our Great Helmsman, Councillor Loakes, may he live for Ten Thousand Years! Long Live Socialist Accountancy! Long Live the Party!

jrp, Leytonstone says...
11:12am Thu 14 Aug 08

Once again the sad fact is the deprived areas that this money was earmarked for are STILL waiting for some improvement money that they will not get.
Loakes and co should hang their heads in shame.

jrp, Leytonstone says...
11:13am Thu 14 Aug 08

Whatever Technomist is on.......I'll have some.

Technomist, Walthamstow says...
12:11pm Thu 14 Aug 08

I have found, after many careful minutes of meditating on the true religious and cultural meaning of the Beijing Olympics, that a more positive and upbeat approach must be adopted by us all if we are to meet our full potential as human beings. I have seen the light which he has so selflessly been trying to bring us thorough his propagation of the Olympic ideal. Seeking to shame Counsillor Loakes for what seems to us ignorant fools as incompetance and inabiltiy is a pointless activity. Far sighted Councillor Loakes moves in mysterious ways, which, we who do not understand the miracle of his Socialist Accountancy are too stupid to fathom.

He is clearly a Higher Being. The ordinary expectations of the citizenry towards their councillors do not apply in the case of our Dear Leader. Instead, we humble folk should recognize his Gold Medal winning superiority over the laws of men. We should all gather at the focal point of our community, before his massive image screened into in our beautiful and well-managed town square to hear choirs of school-children sing songs in his honour and listen to golden haired maidens recite poetry to his praise. Our Great Helsman must be rightly praised and worshiped by us lesser mortals. We who are not worthy to receive his WFM Good News through our letterboxes should cut out his photograph and carry it in our fast-depleting wallets, reminding ourselves constantly of his wise words and great achievements.

Long Live Councillor Loakes! Ten Thousand Years to Councillor Loakes!

dbisping, Chingford says...
12:22pm Thu 14 Aug 08

The scary thing is how close to the truth 'Technomist' actually is, with the council website extolling how wonderful the Great Leader is, to LBWF's answer to Pravda being stuffed thru everyone letterbox fortnightly.

If you tell the great unwashed masses how wonderful you are in enough ways people will start believing and go back to being quiet and leave the running of the council to those who know it's their right to do so

Dave Hall, Walthamstow says...
12:53pm Thu 14 Aug 08

Allow Technomist the intoxication of euphoria, the original mood-lifting drug. These revelations come after so much dreary battling.
In our house we are now thinking of council expenditure in a new unit: the St James. This is said the be the amount of money it took to run the St James Street library for one year. The £1million is over 14 St James's. The Great Helmsman is worth about three quarters of a St James.
But let us not fall into the trap of the cult of the personality. There are all Loakes's accomplices in the local Labour party - all those councillors vote his way, and so of course do the LibDems, who keep this increasingly unsavoury-looking council going for reasons known to themselves. Do not let any of them escape retribution when the day of reckoning and auditing comes.
Dear Leaders eventually prove too dear...

Walthamster, Walthamstow says...
3:44pm Thu 14 Aug 08

"Cllr Loakes has refused to accept responsibility for the failings and says the problems were the result of council procedures not being followed and have nothing to do with the LSP."

So Clyde Loakes, chairman of the LSP, is palming off responsibility onto Waltham Forest council, whose leader is ... Clyde Loakes.

Brilliant!

The only thing I don't understand is why the Labour group have kept Loakes as their leader, and why the Lib Dems keep backing him.

Nick Tiratsoo first started uncovering these scandals in 2004. Even the most mindless supporter of The Great Helmsman might have had time to work out that the ship's sinking.

Your sayYour Guardian

comment Add your comment

Register for a FREE East London and West Essex Guardian Series account and you can have your say on today's news and sport by adding comments on articles we publish. The best comments may even get published in the paper.

Please register now or sign in below to continue.


Local Advertisers

Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »