Waltham Forest News RSS Feed


WALTHAM FOREST: Teachers concerned over religious holiday school closures


COMPULSORY school closures for minority religious holidays have sparked concerns among teachers.

The dates for the new school year 2010/11 were agreed last month by the council and include a requirement for community schools to close during Eid-Ul-Fitr, Guru Nanak and Diwali.

But headteachers across Waltham Forest have criticised the decision, saying schools should be allowed to determine their own closures for religious days.

One heasteacher said: “For a school such as Kelmscott where the vast majority of pupils are either Christian or Muslim, there is no need to take additional time out for Diwali or Guru Nanak.

“However, the school does promote and celebrate these events allowing the very small number of staff or pupils to have religious absence days if they request.”

She added that schools should be allowed to decide whether or not to allow religious holidays based on their own circumstances.

And Ian Moyes, Waltham Forest secretary of teachers' union NASUWT, along with the Teachers' Joint Committee (TJC), called on the council to drop the requirement.

A headteacher of a Walthamstow School said: “We remain frustrated by the requirement on all schools, regarding of the religious profile of the staff and student populations, to close for Hindu, Muslim and Sikh festivals.”

Community schools will be required to close on all three days while foundation and voluntary aided schools will be able to make their own decision. A school coaching coordinator, called it a 'political' decision, saying: “If you compare the holidays to 20 years ago, all the changes are to do with political decisions, not what is best for the staff and students in gaining a rest.”

The council confirmed the policy is in place to 'raise awareness of different faiths and cultures within the school community which in turn supports cohesion for the wider community'.

Councillor Liaquat Ali, cabinet member for children and young people, said: “I am aware of the concerns that have been raised and have asked that a review is carried out to identify exactly what holidays Waltham Forest’s children, parents and teachers feel are most appropriate to celebrate during term time.”


Your Say Your Guardian

Malcolm Yeoman, Upper Leytonstone says...
8:01pm Fri 2 Oct 09

Councillor Liaquat Ali, cabinet member for children and young people, said: “I am aware of the concerns that have been raised and have asked that a review is carried out to identify exactly what holidays Waltham Forest’s children, parents and teachers feel are most appropriate to celebrate during term time.”

He should know as he is the Master of keeping his daughter out of school then dodging the fine imposed (see Guardian passim)

Investigations, Victoria BC says...
8:30pm Fri 2 Oct 09

Never heard of any Eid-Ul-Fitr, Guru Nanak or Diwali in either Walthamstow, Waltham or Woodford and suspect they may be something to do with Dulali-tap of which there have been outbreaks in the distant past! Perhaps students who are sufficiently well grounded in their studies to permit their absence from class should devote some time to learning the traditions of the country which their parents have chosen for them!

Brendasfriend, Leyton says...
10:30pm Fri 2 Oct 09

Where have you all been for the last 20 years? Waltham Forest 'community' schools have been closing for Eid, Diwali and Guru Nanak's Birthday for about that long. All the faith groups in the borough were asked how they wanted their religious holidays to be recognised and those particular groups asked for schools to be closed for the day. You might not like it but you can't pin the idea on this lot of councillors - they wouldn't have the imagination.

EWX, East of London says...
9:10am Sat 3 Oct 09

What about Passover and Yom Kippur and Rosh Hashanna?
The Jewish faith has been part of our fabric for centuries and members of it have contributed a great deal, yet they have never DEMANDED special treatment.
An example to follow I think.

Helen, Walthamstow, Walthamstow says...
10:28am Sat 3 Oct 09

When the idea of single day holidays to mark the various community religions in schools was first mooted about 20 years ago, the Jewish Board of Deputies was approached to suggest which of its festivals it would like included.

The Board decided not to take up the offer, as long as the existing arrangement - that people of faith are allowed to take time off for special holy days - was continued. It has been continued.

Larry Green, chigwell says...
11:03am Sat 3 Oct 09

how about a special day for jedi enthusiasts.......


i mean darth vader is still a much loved figure in E17

Techno2, Walthamstow says...
1:17pm Sat 3 Oct 09

Larry Green wrote:
how about a special day for jedi enthusiasts....... i mean darth vader is still a much loved figure in E17
Many of the skeptical materialists - who are broably the majority now, after all, may well value a day off to go shopping.

Walthamster, Walthamstow says...
4:25pm Sat 3 Oct 09

I sympathise with the teachers, and with working parents who will have to organize around these extra days off. This is a political intrusion into education. Enforcing days off for religions that may not have a single pupil at the school shows what a silly bit of political correctness this is.

Like so many of these silly ideas, it doesn't 'support cohesion for the wider community', it underlines and increases the divisions.

myopinioncounts, Walthamstow says...
5:11pm Sun 4 Oct 09

The closure of schools for Eid has always been problematic.
Although the phases of the moon are fixed, Ramadam starts with the sighting of the new moon. One Mosque may state that the moon has been sighted and Ramadam will be the next day, another may say that it has not and Ramadam may be a different day for their worshippers. On top of that the day chosen by the Borough may not be either of those days.
In Waltham Forest schools where an increasing number of pupils and staff are Moslem there may be up to three days in that week when staff cover, school meals and the timetable cannot be planned in advance.
Imagine if Christian staff were to announce only one day in advance that they would be taking the next day off to celebrate Christmas.

Comments are closed on this article.


Local Advertisers

Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »