News RSS Feed


WALTHAM FOREST: Library books appeal as child literacy levels fall

4:42pm Wednesday 5th December 2007

comment Comments (12)   Have your say »

By Sarah Cosgrove »

BOOK lovers have called for local library policy to be changed after studies published this week found the educational standards of our children were declining.

England dropped from third to 19th in the 45-country league table of children's literacy levels which looked at reading, writing and comprehension among ten-year-olds.

The study, which was last conducted five years ago, found that England lagged behind Russia, Canada, the USA and Singapore, and several European states.

Investigators found that 37 per cent of our children played computer games far more than three hours a day and blamed parents and target and test-driven national policy for the decline.

A separate study of 57 countries showed that 15-year-olds had plummeted from 7th to 17th in reading in six years.

Ministers pledged £5m for new books in nurseries but parents in Waltham Forest said improvements need to be made closer to home.

IT professional David Slack, of Rectory Road, Walthamstow, said he worried about the educational cultural future for his children, Cora, four, Phoebe, five, and Tim, nine.

"There comes a point when you stop going to the library just because there is a lack of choice," he said. "As kids get older and get to secondary school, they have to do research and homework and their local library is somewhere to go to do that.

"We need a state of the art multi-media library for young and old people alike."

Artist and father Mark Hampson, who lectures at The Royal College of Art, was shocked when he could not find an illustrated children's bible in Walthamstow Central Library, after spending half-an-hour searching.

And the St James St Library campaigners have demanded that money be found in next year's budget to reopen their library, which they said was used by several schools.

"Children need libraries and libraries need books," said campaigner Caroline Molloy. "This is particularly critical for the academic success of children growing up in low income families.

"Computers in libraries are great, but no replacement for books. There is plenty of academic evidence that people take in information better from a printed page than a computer screen."


Your Say Your Guardian

kal, walthamstow says...
8:28pm Wed 5 Dec 07

Fish tanks and computers may make the library more attractive to some users, but it is not the point of a library. Books are the library's reason for being. The free market caters very well for internet access. Hours of access for a £1 or less. But nowhere other than a library will give you access to books for 3 weeks for free. (and then you can renew them)Nowhere but a library can you spend hours researching your topic in a quiet and conducive environment. And with the research showing that we retain more information from the printed page than a computer screen, the emphasis should be on books, not computers. Computers, playstations, and djs may get people into libraries, but it will not help them learn. Libraries were creatd to help educate all, so that not just those who could afford to buy books could learn. It is clear that allowing libraries to run down their book stocks and emphasise computers has had a dramatically bad effect on the literacy of our children. This policy must be reversed.

Caroline, Walthamstow says...
9:53pm Wed 5 Dec 07

Come to the St James St Library Campaign's fun day, this Saturday (8th) at 2pm outside the library - free face painting with Carole from Big Brother, music, bring a book to swap, and making xmas cards to tell the council what you think of the library cuts and closures. All welcome! (rain or shine!). See www.stjamesstlibrary
.wordpress.com for more details.

Janet Wright, Walthamstow says...
10:58pm Wed 5 Dec 07

You can get an hour's Internet access at any one of half a dozen shops on the High Street for 40p to 50p.

But you can't borrow books anywhere except a library.

Cut down on libraries and you cut down on children's reading abilities. Along with that, you cut down their chances of doing well at school and throughout life. That's not my opinion, but a fact confirmed by numerous published studies.

The least harm comes to children in middle-class households with plenty of books -- such as a well-paid councillor could afford.

The children who lose out most are those in crowded households in deprived areas -- for example, around St James Street library.

My parents had to leave school for work in their early teens. We owned hardly any books, but they took me to the local public library every week. Books introduced me to a world of possiibilities I could never have imagined, and I went on to study and get a good job and not have to work myself to death like my parents.

I owe more to libraries than I could ever repay. Because of all they did for me, I would do anything to keep them as a resource for future generations.

It breaks my heart to see people like Clyde Loakes, who have a university education, pulling up the ladder behind them and denying chances to children who need the help libraries gave to people like him and me.

Don't feed our children on garbage. Respect them enough to give them the chances we had: to open the treasure chest of world literature, to be challenged, educated and inspired. Don't trap them in simple-minded mediocrity. Let them have a future.

Come and celebrate St James Street Library, Coppermill Lane, on Saturday afternoon 8 December. We may be outside, there will be books for all!

mdj, e10 says...
9:00pm Thu 6 Dec 07

Its very timely that Dolly Parton, one of 12 children of illiterate parents, should be in the country to promote a book scheme for children. By contrast I grew up with literally thousands of books in the house, and still the libraries were a lifeline. Can the Council not see that those protesting are those who have had to educate themselves the hard way? 'Pulling up the ladder', Antony Crosland's prophecy from the fifties, says it all.Can we get Dolly Parton to come here? She'd give Loakes and Co what for!

Sceptic, Walthamstow says...
10:50pm Thu 6 Dec 07

Dolly Parton is honest and generous, she made good through her own talent and wants other people's children to have the best possible chances.

This council is the exact opposite. Big fish in a small pond, they're doing well out of council-tax payers and don't want anyone else to get ideas.

Voting to close a library and give themselves a big pay rise at the same time would seem unbelievable anywhere else. With this crowd, it's par for the course.

Tom, Walthamstow says...
10:26pm Sun 9 Dec 07

The Council has done a massive refurbishment programme and I'm really impressed with Walthamstow Library!

I find plenty of books there for my kids and if I can't the staff order them in for me.

what?!?, st James Street says...
11:34pm Sun 9 Dec 07

hello Tom, you're doing a thoroughly committed job of supporting the council's stand and policy as regards our libraries - I wonder, Tom, are you employed by teh council in some sort of propiganda role perhaps? In their own little Ministry of Truth? I would refer readers to another comments page on here (this one related to the destruction of 239,000+ library books by 'our' council) which is quite revealing, to say the least:
http://www.guardian-
series.co.uk/display
.var.1866925.0.0.php
#comments

I wonder if we did a search, how many other pro-council comments we would find from council Tom ...? Maybe you are one of our beloved councillors, Tom, is that it, spending so much time supporting our libraries that they are never available to take the rap when they get caught out? - sorry Tom, I'm not convinced.


mark hart, Walthamstow says...
10:57am Mon 10 Dec 07

I'm also sceptical about Tom's comments.

How long does it take to receive a book when you ask staff to order it. On the occassions I've done this it's taken months.

The central library is poor and in my opinion, worse since the catastrophic refurbishment.

hmmmm, Leyton says...
1:33pm Mon 10 Dec 07

Ok, after the bonfire of books and various other library related silliness, It starts to become clear that the people in charge may not have the best interests of the local people in the forefront of there decision making. So what to do? well its your library, you pay for it, so in that vain you are at the heart of getting the message across to the council. I am in many ways a little immature and think the protest should be fitting to the crime. The library has about 50 000+ books, and each adult can take out 8. So if a little protest was organised what I would do is set a date lets say hmmmm First week in January. And then suggest that any adults in Walthamstow should take advantage of their 8 book limit. And maybe they could take the first 8 book from a particular section lets say hmmm 'Science and nature'. So with a minimum number of people even as low as 20 that's , 160 books gone. Infact you could clear an entire section. Then I don't know maybe some one slip a little call to a local newspaper.....hmmmmm .

Book Fan, E17 says...
8:07pm Mon 10 Dec 07

Hi Tom
Really surprised with your comments. Either you are paid to speak for the council or from another planet? ~Wake up Tom. You are in cuckoo land with your comments!

The council had done a massive redesigned program at Central library costing us £3.5m. The workmanship is shoddy with squeaky flooring, leaking roof, dangerous automatic doors, etc. Now the flooring is ripped apart after 9 months being installed to reveal uneven cement floor underneath. Who is paying for the fixing of this problem - the contractors or taxpayers? The council is mismanaging our funds and they should be accountable to us for their actions.

We need books not fish tank in libraries. What happened to all those books before the library was redesigned? I remembered there were lots of books and magazines in the reference section. Now there is hardly any in that department. Where are the books?
What is the use of fish tank in a library? Cllr Reardon said to create an ambience. What utter rubbish! The £8000 + vat could be put to better use instead. The council said they have no money to run St James Library and such wastage here! If money is properly spent, there is no problem to keep St James open. For a start – sell off the fish tanks in the borough’s communal places. Greenery is much better and more cost effective.

Over 2000 people cannot be wrong about what the council has been doing. Think Tom, and do not be deceived.


Walthamstower, London says...
8:21pm Mon 10 Dec 07

Children should be encouraged from young to read and enjoy books and not spend their time on electronic consoles.

St James area is quite deprived and taking away their much needed library will bring down the standard of the children academic performance in the near future. Statistics speak for itself that UK is now going down in the literacy league tables.

Personally, I have seen children lagging behind in their literacy especially the ethnic minorities.
Computers cannot replace libraries. It only encourages people to be couch potatoes and resulting in health problems and being obese.

Give us back our library to improve!

mdj, e10 says...
12:04am Tue 11 Dec 07

Tom,
I'm glad to say that the book ordering process has always worked well in this borough. However, the real power of a library is when you walk in and are blown away to discover a topic or writer that hadn't crossed your path before. That's why internet access is no substitute: you need to know what you're looking for in advance, or the librarian needs to be quite empathetic to your needs. Since we now have NO qualified librarians (that should surely appal you),that's less likely to happen. BTW, can you state where you stand on the deliberate and secretive destruction of OUR books, many of great value?

Your sayYour Guardian

comment Add your comment

Register for a FREE East London and West Essex Guardian Series account and you can have your say on today's news and sport by adding comments on articles we publish. The best comments may even get published in the paper.

Please register now or sign in below to continue.




Forgotten your password?
Riaz Jaffari reading to children during a Lea Bridge Library fun day in a bid to interest them in books (EL1070-30016) Riaz Jaffari reading to children during a Lea Bridge Library fun day in a bid to interest them in books (EL1070-30016)

Hot Jobs

E-editions


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »